Category: Investing

  • What Changes in Markets, and What Doesn’t

    What Changes in Markets, and What Doesn’t

    Markets move in ways that feel unpredictable. The investors who come out ahead are rarely the ones who predicted correctly. They are the ones who stayed disciplined when it mattered most.

    A client called us in October 2022. The S&P 500 was down roughly 25% for the year. He had been a steady, patient investor for more than two decades. He had lived through the dot-com crash. He had lived through 2008. He called to tell us he was thinking about moving everything to cash.

    We asked him one question: what has changed about your plan?

    He paused. “Nothing,” he said. “I just can’t stand watching it anymore.”

    That is the honest version of what market volatility actually does to investors. It doesn’t change the plan. It changes how the plan feels. And when how the plan feels becomes the basis for what you do next, the damage is rarely the market’s doing.

    The Part That Keeps Changing

    Markets are not stable. They are not meant to be. They reflect the collective judgment of millions of participants, updated continuously, based on every piece of available information and a significant amount of emotion. Prices move because expectations change, because fear spikes, because new information arrives, because yesterday’s conviction becomes today’s doubt.

    What changes, constantly and without warning, is price. Valuations shift. Sectors fall in and out of favor. Interest rates move. Currency relationships flip. A company that led the market for five years underperforms for the next three. A country that was irrelevant becomes important. These are the things that keep changing, and they will keep changing indefinitely, regardless of how sophisticated any observer’s forecast becomes.

    Anyone who tells you they know, with confidence, what markets will do next quarter is telling you something that no consistent evidence supports.

    The Part That Doesn’t

    What does not change is the long-run behavior of markets in aggregate. Economies grow over time. Productive companies create value over time. Investors who participate in that growth, across a diversified range of assets, over long enough periods, have historically been rewarded for doing so.

    This is not a guarantee. It is a pattern that has held across a very long history, through wars, panics, depressions, financial crises, and political disruptions. The pattern has never been smooth. It has always involved periods that felt like it was ending. It has not ended.

    What else does not change: human behavior under pressure. Investors reliably buy after markets have risen and sell after markets have fallen. They move to safety at the worst possible time. They return to equities after missing the recovery. This pattern repeats itself across generations, market cycles, and levels of financial sophistication. It is not a character flaw. It is a predictable response to uncertainty, and it is the primary reason most individual investors underperform the markets they invest in.

    The Real Risk Most Investors Underestimate

    Conventional thinking frames market risk as the risk that prices will fall. That is a real risk, and it matters. But it is not the risk that does the most damage to long-term outcomes.

    The more consequential risk is the risk of a badly timed decision. Moving to cash after a significant decline and waiting for confidence to return before getting back in. Selling a position that was down and then watching it recover. Adding risk after a long rally and then absorbing a correction. These are not hypothetical mistakes. They happen to disciplined, well-intentioned investors with good advisors, repeatedly, because the pressure to act during volatility is enormous and the feedback loops are confusing.

    A portfolio that experiences market declines and recovers with the market will, in most cases, produce a better outcome than a portfolio that avoids declines by exiting and then misses the recovery trying to get back in. The math on this is not subtle.

    What Discipline Actually Looks Like

    Discipline is not the same as inaction. A disciplined investor does things. They rebalance when allocations drift. They adjust their portfolio as their time horizon and risk tolerance change. They consider tax efficiency across their holdings. These are active decisions, made deliberately, based on the plan rather than on what markets did last week.

    What discipline does not do is respond to short-term price movement as though it contains information about what the investor should do next. A 10% decline is not information that the plan is wrong. A strong quarter is not information that the allocation should be increased. The market is always doing something. The question is whether what it is doing is relevant to what you specifically should do.

    For most long-term investors, the answer most of the time is: not particularly.

    Why Having an Advisor Matters Here

    The role of an advisor during volatile markets is not primarily analytical. It is structural. The advisor is the person who has already thought through what you should do if markets fall 20%, before markets fall 20%. That conversation, held in advance and committed to in writing, is what makes it possible to not make a decision during the event itself.

    It is much easier to stay disciplined when you have already decided what discipline looks like. It is much easier to hold a position when you already know, with someone who has looked at your numbers, that the position is consistent with your plan. The advisor is not predicting. The advisor is helping you not react.

    That is a specific and valuable service. It is most visible during the periods when you most want to do something you should not.

    The Client Who Called

    The client who called us in October 2022 did not move to cash. We walked through what had changed. We walked through what had not. We reviewed his plan and confirmed that it had been built to survive a year like that one. He stayed invested.

    By the end of 2023, his portfolio had recovered what it lost and then some. He did not tell us we had predicted anything correctly. What he said was that he was glad he had called before doing something he couldn’t undo.

    That is what the relationship is for.

    A Place to Start

    If market volatility has you questioning your strategy, or if you don’t have a clear answer to what you would do if markets dropped significantly from here, that is worth a conversation. Not to predict what markets will do. To make sure your plan already accounts for the fact that they will move.

    A complimentary portfolio review with a Townsend CFP® professional is an opportunity to evaluate whether your current investment strategy remains aligned with your goals, risk tolerance, and long-term financial plan.

    Coloradans have trusted us with that conversation since 1990. We’d be glad to have it with you.

    Schedule a complimentary portfolio review →

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Q: Does market timing ever work?

    A: Occasionally, and unpredictably. The challenge is that you have to be right twice: when to get out and when to get back in. Investors who exit successfully often stay out too long, waiting for certainty before returning, and miss a significant portion of the recovery. Research has generally shown that consistently and successfully timing market movements is difficult to achieve over long periods.

    Q: My neighbor says he moved to bonds before the last drop and saved himself a lot of pain. Why shouldn’t I do that?

    A: What your neighbor is describing is a good outcome from a single decision. The relevant question is whether he had a disciplined process for making that decision, or whether it was a view he held that happened to be correct that time. Most individual investors who rotate to safety based on market forecasts underperform over time, because they do not make the same call correctly with the same reliability as the first instance suggests.

    Q: How should I think about market drops if I am already retired?

    A: Differently than an investor who is still accumulating, because your time horizon and cash flow needs are different. A retired household needs to fund near-term income from assets that are not all exposed to equity volatility, and the sequencing of returns matters more than it did during the accumulation years. This is a planning conversation as much as an investment one, and it is worth having specifically, not generally.

    Q: What is the right allocation during volatile markets?

    A: The right allocation during volatile markets is the same as the right allocation before them: the one consistent with your time horizon, your income needs, and your genuine risk tolerance. If your current allocation feels wrong during volatility, the issue is usually that the allocation was set based on a risk tolerance that was assessed during calm conditions and turned out to be optimistic. That is a common problem and worth addressing deliberately.

    Q: Does Townsend use active management or index funds?

    A: Both, depending on the client’s situation, the asset class in question, and where we believe active management has a reasonable basis. We do not have a house ideology on this. We have a fiduciary obligation to use whatever approach is most appropriate for the specific household, and that is the standard we apply.

    Q: How often should I be reviewing my investment strategy?

    A: At minimum, annually, and any time there is a meaningful change in your financial situation, your time horizon, or your goals. During periods of significant market movement, a check-in is worth it not to change the strategy, but to confirm that it still makes sense to hold it. That confirmation is often more valuable than any adjustment.

    Schedule a complimentary portfolio review →

    Important Disclosure

    This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. Past market performance is not indicative of future results. All investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Actual results will vary based on individual circumstances, market conditions, and other factors.

  • Why Reacting to Headlines Creates More Risk

    Why Reacting to Headlines Creates More Risk

    The question “should I be doing something right now?” feels responsible. Acting on it, most of the time, is not.

    A client called on a Tuesday morning after a rough few days in the market. She had been watching the news the night before. There was a segment about inflation, a separate one about interest rates, and a third one about a geopolitical situation she didn’t fully understand. By the time she went to bed, she was convinced that something was about to happen and that she needed to do something before it did.

    “I just feel like I should be moving things around,” she said. “Shouldn’t I be doing something?”

    We asked her what specifically had changed about her situation, her timeline, or her goals since we had last reviewed her plan together.

    Nothing, she said. Everything she described was in the news.

    That distinction matters more than most investors realize, and it sits at the center of one of the most consistent ways people reduce their own returns without knowing it.

    What Headlines Are Designed to Do

    Financial news is not designed to help you make better investment decisions. It is designed to hold your attention. Those are different objectives, and they produce different kinds of content.

    Attention is captured by urgency. Urgency requires a sense that something is happening right now that you need to know about. In financial media, that translates into a continuous stream of events framed as potentially decisive: a Fed statement, an earnings miss, a jobs report, a political development, a foreign market move. Each one is presented as though it might be the thing that changes everything.

    Most of them are not. Some of them matter at the margin. A very small number of them turn out to be genuinely significant over a long time horizon. The problem is that the presentation is identical for all three categories. Everything sounds like it might be the one that matters. Nothing sounds routine.

    When you consume enough of this content, the rational response feels like action. Staying put feels like complacency. Watching your portfolio while the headlines roll and doing nothing feels almost irresponsible.

    That feeling is the mechanism. It is not a signal. It is a byproduct of how the content is made.

    The Cost of Acting on That Feeling

    The research on investor behavior is consistent and has been for decades. Individual investors, on average, underperform the funds they invest in. The gap exists not because they pick bad funds, but because they move in and out of those funds at the wrong times, typically buying after strong performance and selling after declines.

    Headlines are one of the primary inputs driving those moves. A negative story creates the feeling that the situation has changed. The feeling creates the impulse to act. The action, taken at a moment of peak anxiety, is often the wrong one. The market recovers, the investor is sitting in cash or a defensive position, and the recovery happens without them.

    This is not a story about a particular type of investor. It happens to sophisticated, educated, financially literate people. It happens to people who understand the theory of long-term investing and believe in it. It happens because the emotional pressure of watching your savings move in real time, against a backdrop of urgent and ominous news coverage, is genuinely difficult to sit with. The impulse to do something is not irrational. It is human.

    Over time, these behaviors may have a negative impact on investment returns.

    Why the Urgency Rarely Matches the Reality

    Consider what financial headlines looked like in almost any year over the past several decades. There was always something alarming. Political instability. Trade disputes. Recession fears. A banking crisis. A technology bubble. A pandemic. A war. An inflation spike. An interest rate cycle.

    Historically, many investors who remained committed to a long-term investment strategy avoided some of the challenges associated with making frequent changes in response to market news and events. Not because the headlines were wrong about the events. Many of the events they described were real and serious. But the connection between a given news event and what a specific investor with a specific plan should do is almost always weaker than the headline implies.

    Markets price in information quickly. By the time you are watching a segment about a risk, that risk is already reflected, at least partially, in asset prices. Acting on news that is already priced in doesn’t protect you. It exposes you to the cost of a transaction and the risk of being wrong about timing.

    The Question Worth Asking Instead

    When the impulse to act arrives, the most useful thing to do is replace the headline-driven question with a different one.

    Instead of: should I be doing something right now?

    Ask: has anything changed about my situation, my timeline, or my goals?

    If the answer is yes, a conversation with your advisor is warranted. Maybe your income situation has shifted. Maybe your time horizon has shortened. Maybe your risk tolerance, honestly assessed, is different than it was when the plan was built. Those are legitimate reasons to revisit the plan.

    If the answer is no, and the only thing that has changed is what you saw on the news last night, the plan does not need to change. The plan was built to account for the fact that markets move and headlines happen. That is part of what it does.

    This reframe is simple. It is not easy. The urgency that headlines create is real even when it is manufactured, and sitting with it requires a specific kind of discipline. But the reframe is correct, and practicing it consistently is one of the more reliable ways to protect your long-term outcomes from your short-term reactions.

    What an Advisor Is Actually For in These Moments

    There is a version of the advisor relationship that most people imagine when they think about what an advisor does: research, fund selection, portfolio construction, tax efficiency. Those things matter. But they are not the part of the relationship that tends to have the most impact on outcomes.

    The part that tends to matter most is the conversation that happens when the client calls on a Tuesday morning after a bad week and a frightening news cycle. The advisor’s job in that moment is not to validate the fear or to dismiss it. It is to do something more useful: walk through what has actually changed, confirm what the plan was built for, and help the client make a decision based on their situation rather than on the last thing they watched.

    That conversation, repeated across years and market cycles, is the actual service. It does not show up in a quarterly report. It shows up in the difference between what the market returned and what the client actually kept.

    A Place to Start

    If you find yourself regularly wondering whether you should be repositioning around current events, that is worth examining, not because the question is unreasonable, but because the answer is almost always the same, and a plan built around that answer is more useful than checking the news every morning.

    A complimentary portfolio review with a Townsend CFP® professional is a straightforward way to find out whether your current investment strategy remains aligned with your goals, risk tolerance, and long-term objectives. Most portfolios that cause anxiety during bad news cycles were not built with enough explicit thought about how they would behave when the news was bad.

    Coloradans have trusted us with that conversation since 1990. We’d be glad to have it with you.

    Schedule a complimentary portfolio review →

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Q: How do I know when a headline actually warrants changing something?

    A: The test is whether it has changed something about your specific situation, not whether it sounds serious. A major policy shift that directly affects an asset class you are heavily concentrated in, at a moment when your time horizon or income needs have also changed, might warrant a conversation. A general story about market uncertainty or economic risk, which describes essentially every year in the market’s history, usually does not. When in doubt, call your advisor before acting, not after.

    Q: Isn’t it better to be cautious when things seem uncertain?

    A: Caution built into a plan from the start is valuable. Caution applied reactively, after a period of bad news, tends to mean selling after prices have already fallen. That is the opposite of what caution is supposed to accomplish. A well-constructed portfolio already has a level of conservatism calibrated to your situation. Adding more in response to headlines usually means adding it at the wrong time and removing it, if ever, after the recovery has already happened.

    Q: What if the news is about something that directly affects my investments?

    A: Then it is worth a conversation with your advisor about whether the exposure is appropriate given your plan. There is a difference between a story about general market conditions and a story about a specific sector, company, or policy that represents a meaningful part of your portfolio. The former is almost never a reason to act. The latter might be worth reviewing. Your advisor can help you tell the difference.

    Q: I find myself checking my portfolio several times a day. Is that a problem?

    A: It can become one. Frequent portfolio checking, particularly during volatile periods, is associated with higher rates of reactive trading, because every check gives you another opportunity to feel like you should do something. Most long-term investors are better served by checking quarterly, or when they have a specific question, rather than in response to daily market movement. If the checking is causing anxiety, that is also worth mentioning to your advisor, because the anxiety may be telling you something about how the portfolio is constructed.

    Q: My brother-in-law says he moves to cash every time the market looks shaky. He seems to do fine.

    A: What you are seeing is the outcomes he talks about. You are not seeing the outcomes he does not talk about, the times the move was wrong and he stayed in cash too long or got back in at the wrong moment. People who describe their tactical moves tend to describe the ones that worked. The evidence on whether this approach outperforms a disciplined long-term strategy, across all the moves and not just the memorable ones, does not generally favor it.

    Q: Should I stop following financial news entirely?

    A: Not necessarily. Being informed is different from being reactive. The problem is not knowing what is happening in markets. The problem is treating that information as a signal for what you personally should do next. You can follow financial news as background and context without acting on it. The discipline is in recognizing that general market commentary, however alarming, is rarely a direct instruction for your specific plan.

    Important Disclosure

    This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. Past market performance is not indicative of future results. All investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Actual results will vary based on individual circumstances, market conditions, and other factors.

    Schedule a complimentary portfolio review →